- Quality Inn Arcola6.5Arcola
- Relax Inn & SuitesMattoon4.3
- Green Mill Village Hotel & Suites, BW Signature CollectionArcola
- Willow e-hotel6.1Mattoon
- Best Western Heartland Inn7.5Mattoon
- Super 8 by Wyndham Mattoon7.7Mattoon
- Hilton Garden Inn Mattoon, IL8.9Mattoon
- Country Home Near EIU and Lake Charleston!Charleston9.7
- Willow e-hotelMattoon
- Unique Suites Hotel7.0Charleston
- End of results -