- Sapphire Beach Club Resort6.9Lowlands
- The Horny Toad Guest HouseSimpson Bay9.5
- Mary's Boon Beach Resort & Spa7.9Simpson Bay
- Baker's SuitesSimpson Bay8.7
- Travel Inn Hotel Simpson Bay6.9Simpson Bay
- The Villas at Simpson Bay Resort8.4Simpson Bay
- Simpson Bay Resort Marina & Spa8.2Simpson Bay
- Seaview Beach Hotel6.7Philipsburg
- La Vista ResortSimpson Bay8.8
- Horizon View Beach HotelPhilipsburg7.4
- End of results -