- Secluded Cabin with Boats Less Than 6 Mi to Jenny Jump!Great Meadows10.0
- The Inn at Stony Creek9.7Warwick
- Ski on Ski off Mtn ChaletVernon7.7
- Quality Inn near Mountain Creek7.5Vernon
- The Appalachian at Mountain Creek7.2Vernon
- Econo Lodge6.6Newton
- Hilton Garden Inn Rockaway8.1Rockaway
- Homewood Suites by Hilton Dover - Rockaway8.8Dover
- Best Western Hunt's Landing Hotel Matamoras Milford8.1Matamoras
- Holiday Inn Express Hotel & Suites Newton Sparta by IHG9.1Newton
- Holiday Inn Express Mount Arlington by IHG9.0Mount Arlington
- Hampton Inn Denville-Rockaway-ParsippanyDenville7.8
- Residence Inn Mount Olive At International Trade CenterStanhope9.0
- Hampton Inn Matamoras8.3Matamoras
- Holiday Inn Budd Lake - Rockaway Area by IHG8.1Budd Lake
- FairBridge Inn Express MilfordMilford7.7
- Scottish Inns Milford8.5Milford
- Appalachian Motel7.0Vernon
- Lake Hopatcong Family Home with Boat Slip and DockHopatcong
- TownePlace Suites by Marriott Dover RockawayDover9.2
- End of results -